We are OPEN during these trying times to make sure we can still support you in all your legal matters.

Please know you can call us to schedule appointments that will be conducted via teleconference or video-conference for any of your legal matters. Be well and stay safe.
Silvi, Fedele & Honschke Attorneys at Law, L.L.C.
Phone 732-504-3841 Toll Free 877-251-5491
En Espanol

Use of circumstantial evidence in personal liability cases

As New Jersey residents may know, establishing negligence is an intricate part of a personal injury lawsuit. Generally, the causal relationship between the injury and another person's negligence must be established showing how he or she deviated from an expected duty of care and caused the injury. Proof might be difficult in some circumstances, and a doctrine called res ipsa loquitur may be used instead.

This doctrine allows circumstantial evidence to be included to infer negligence. For instance, if a plaintiff is bitten by a neighbor's dog, he or she must prove the neighbor negligently did not lock the gate, allowing the dog to leave the yard. Using res ipsa loquitur, the plaintiff may insist that the dog roaming the neighborhood proves the gate was not locked. The circumstance speaks for itself.

The use of circumstantial evidence helps the court determine if the correlation between the event and the defendant's alleged negligence is likely. The use of circumstantial evidence in premises liability cases demands that certain parameters be shown. The plaintiff must establish that an event does not normally happen. When it does, it is caused by a negligent act and not caused by the injured party, and the defendant had a duty to prevent the injury. However, the defendant failed in that duty, which caused a situation that resulted in harm or injury. This shows a causal relationship between the negligent act and the injury and damages.

When someone is injured by the negligence of another, the individual may suffer financial damage in addition to physical injury. The individual may wish to recover pecuniary damage associated with loss of employment and medical care as well as pain and suffering. An attorney may help by reviewing the accident and filing a personal injury lawsuit.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Have A Legal Question?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Our Office Locations

Toms River Office
189 Route 37 West
Suite 1
Toms River, NJ 08755

Toll Free: 877-251-5491
Phone: 732-504-3841
Toms River Law Office Map

Forked River Office
623 Lacey Road
Suite 3
Forked River, NJ 08731

Toll Free: 877-251-5491
Phone: 732-504-3841
Map & Directions

Bricktown Office
74 Brick Boulevard
Building 2, Suite 112, Unit 3
Bricktown, NJ 08723

Toll Free: 877-251-5491
Phone: 732-504-3841
Map & Directions